In one of the very few studies of children during actual
exposure to war conditions, Maureen Allwood, Debora Bell-Dolan, and
Syed Arshad Husain (2002) assessed 791 Bosnian children during the siege
of Sarajevo. Interviewers obtained children's scores on the PTSD Reaction
Index, the War Experience Questionnaire, the Impact of Events Scale,
and the Children's Depression Inventory. Teachers completed the Bosnian
version of the Teacher's Report Form (TRF). The largest correlations
found for specific wartime experiences with any psychological or behavioral
measures were between being threatened with direct violence and TRF
Anxious/Depressed scores and also between witnessing killing and TRF
Delinquent Behavior (now called Rule-Breaking Behavior) scores. Furthermore,
children who were not exposed to direct violence, deprivation, or relocation
obtained significantly lower scores on all TRF scales than children
who were exposed to violence, deprivation, or relocation. Children with
the largest number of violent trauma experiences obtained significantly
higher scores on the TRF Anxious/Depressed, Somatic Problems, and Delinquent
Behavior syndromes than other children. However, children who had the
most numerous nonviolent trauma experiences obtained significantly higher
scores than other children on the TRF Withdrawn syndrome. Because not
only direct exposure to violence but indirect exposure and exposure
to nonviolent deprivation were associated with higher TRF problem scores,
the authors concluded that ". . . children may be best served by
efforts to reduce the compounded effects of multiple traumas. For example,
reducing exposure to indirect violence, such as graphic media coverage
of war atrocities, and providing comfort from fears of starvation and
freezing, may be functionally as helpful to children's adjustment as
reducing their direct exposure to violence" (p. 457).
Reference:
Allwood, M.A., Bell-Dolan, D., & Husain, S.A. (2002). Children's
trauma and adjustment reactions to violent and nonviolent war experiences.
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry,
41, 450-457.